Painted metal shingles vs. stone-coated steel
| Painted metal shingles | Stone-coated steel | Standing seam (for reference) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Look from the street | Shingle or shake pattern, smooth painted finish | Shingle, shake or tile with a stone texture | Clean vertical seams |
| Fasteners | Hidden | Mostly hidden in the laps | Hidden under the seam |
| Joints | Many small pieces | Many small pieces | Fewest: one panel eave to ridge |
| Finish that can wear | Factory paint | Stone granules | Factory paint |
| BMR warranty | 30 years | Not installed by BMR | 40 yrs double lock · 30 yrs snap lock |
More on the granule option in is stone-coated steel roofing worth it?
How does shingle-look metal compare with standing seam?
A metal shingle roof gives you the traditional look; standing seam gives you the fewest places for water to get in. Standing seam panels run in one piece from eave to ridge, while a shingle-look roof is built from many smaller interlocking pieces, each with its own joints. Our warranties reflect that: 40 years on double lock standing seam, 30 years on painted metal shingles.
Price runs the other way. Standing seam is our standard roof at about $8 to $16 per square foot installed, and painted metal shingles are priced as a premium upgrade above it: on a typical home, about 15% more than the same roof in standing seam. You are paying for the look.
Who should choose a metal roof that looks like shingles?
- Older and historic homes, where vertical seams would stand out on the street.
- HOA neighborhoods that call for a shingle or shake appearance.
- Owners who love cedar shake but not the upkeep or fire risk of real wood.
If the look does not matter much to you, standing seam is the better value for every year of roof you get. If it does matter, a shingle-look metal roof still gives you steel instead of asphalt.
What to ask before you buy shingle-look metal
- What exactly does the warranty cover? Ask about labor, the panels and the paint or granule finish separately.
- Do you tear off to the deck? Interlocking pieces need a flat, sound base. We never install over rotten or damaged decking.
- How are valleys, walls and chimneys flashed? Most leaks on any metal roof start at those details.
- Where can I see one you installed? Shingle-look metal is a specialty product, so ask for an address and go look.
Driving past real roofs is the best test there is. One customer, Laura H., gathered quotes from seven contractors over two months; Isaac answered her follow-up questions and pointed her to past projects she could drive by before she chose us.
Which metal shingles do we install?
We install painted steel shingles from Green American Home in two styles: the Centura Steel Shingle, for a traditional shingle look, and the Great American Shake, for the look of cedar shake. Both are interlocking steel pieces with hidden fasteners.
Our take. Brothers Metal Roofing installs painted metal shingles, not stone-coated steel. If you want a metal roof that looks like shingles, we will price it next to standing seam so you can see what the look costs. Call (937) 423-9352 or request a free estimate.
Related questions
- Is Stone-Coated Steel Roofing Worth It?
- Is a Metal Roof Better Than Shingles?
- What Is the Best Type of Metal Roofing?
- How much does a metal roof cost in Ohio?
- All metal roof questions

