4.7 · 55 Google reviews Mon–Fri, 7 AM–5 PM Greenville, OH · Serving western Ohio & eastern Indiana

Cost · Replacement

How Much Does It Cost to Replace a Metal Roof?

Replacing a roof with a new standing seam metal roof costs about $8 to $16 per square foot installed in western Ohio and eastern Indiana, which usually puts an average home around $20,000 to $40,000. Replacing an old metal roof costs about the same per foot for the new roof. What changes the total is the tear-off: old metal, screws, purlins and whatever lies underneath take more labor and disposal than a single layer of shingles.

By Isaac Smith, Brothers Metal Roofing · Updated November 2026

Crew tearing off the cedar shake that sat under a 70 to 80 year old metal roof on a Lynn, Indiana home

What a metal roof replacement price includes

  • The new roof system. Panels, clips, trims and flashings. Standing seam is our standard roof at about $8 to $16 per square foot installed.
  • Tear-off and disposal. On standing seam jobs we tear off to the decking. One layer of shingles comes off quickly. Old metal over cedar shake does not.
  • Decking repairs. We never install over rotten or damaged decking. Bad boards are cut out and replaced with new OSB, and the written estimate explains how that is priced before work starts.
  • Underlayment. Ice and water shield and synthetic underlayment go down before any metal.
  • Extras. Seamless gutters and guards, snow guards, chimney work and new pipe boots.

Replacing an old metal roof: a real example

On a two-story home in Lynn, Indiana, the old metal roof was probably 70 to 80 years old, laid over cedar shake on lath. The back of the house had a flat rubber roof and the front porch had shingles. We tore all of it off, wood purlins included, put down new 5/8-inch OSB, and installed 26-gauge double lock standing seam over the whole house.

That roof is about 1,900 square feet. At $8 to $16 per square foot, a roof that size works out to roughly $15,200 to $30,400 before extras. Three old roofs to remove, new decking, re-sloping the flat roof and a full 6-inch gutter system with guards all push a job like this toward the top of the range. This is arithmetic on our published range, not that customer’s invoice.

Replacing an exposed-fastener roof with standing seam

The owners of a Xenia, Ohio farmhouse had an old TuffRib exposed-fastener roof and wanted the look of standing seam. We replaced it with textured black snap lock standing seam. At about 5,000 to 5,200 square feet, that is a big roof: at our published range, a roof that size works out to roughly $40,000 to $83,200.

Replacing shingles with metal

Most of the roofs we replace are asphalt shingles. On the same house, a standing seam quote usually comes in at about 2.5 times a shingle quote. In return you get a roof that typically lasts 40 to 70 years instead of 15 to 25. On a Centerville, Ohio ranch, the tear-off also turned up a large section of rotten decking, which we replaced before the new roof went on. More in is a metal roof better than shingles?

Repair or replace an old metal roof?

Not every old metal roof needs replacing. Most leaks we see on service calls come from very old metal roofs and from the details: pipe boots, chimneys, vent boxes and dormers. Those can often be repaired. Replacement makes sense when the paint is worn through and rust has set in across the panels, as on the Lynn roof, or when the roof keeps leaking in new places.

On exposed-fastener roofs, we recommend a check at 10 years, at 15 years, then every 5 years. Not sure what you have? Text photos of your roof to (937) 423-9352. See metal roof repair and how to fix a leaking metal roof.

Our take. How much does it cost to replace a metal roof? Plan on about $8 to $16 per square foot installed for standing seam, plus whatever the tear-off turns up. The only way to know your number is for someone to look at the roof. Estimates are free and written. Call (937) 423-9352.

Related questions

Straight answers

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to replace a metal roof with shingles?

Up front, yes. A standing seam quote usually runs about 2.5 times a shingle quote on the same house. Shingles typically last 15 to 25 years against 40 to 70 for metal, though, so over the life of the house metal is often the cheaper roof.

Can you put a new metal roof over an old metal roof?

On standing seam jobs, Brothers Metal Roofing tears off to the decking, as on its Lynn, Indiana job, so rotten decking and old fasteners are not sealed under the new roof.

How long does it take to replace a metal roof?

It depends on size and complexity. One customer who had three two-story homes re-roofed by our crews reported each took about 3 to 4 days.

Free estimates · Mon–Fri, 7 AM–5 PM

Let’s look at your roof.

Free inspection and a written estimate. No pressure, and an honest answer on repair vs. replace.

(937) 423-9352
  • 5265 Sebring Warner Rd, Greenville, OH 45331
  • 40-yr Double Lock Warranty
  • 4.7 from 55 Google reviews

Get your free estimate

Fill out our short form and we reply within one business day, usually sooner.

  • Free, written estimate
  • No-pressure roof inspection
  • Honest repair-or-replace advice
Request my free estimate Call (937) 423-9352

Mon–Fri, 7 AM–5 PM

Call nowFree estimate